Joined: Aug 2017 Posts: 981 Threads: 97
Reputation:
3
Location: Cheshire
This seems to back up what has been said about dehumidifiers, then?!
Colin
Joined: Aug 2017 Posts: 806 Threads: 71
Reputation:
9
Can anyone recommend a dehumidifier for colder conditions?
I bought a Trotec dessicant dehumidifier but (despite the specification) it would only work above 10 degrees c. Not much use in the Highlands as I can't really justify heating the garage for 8 months of the year!
Peter.
Joined: Nov 2018 Posts: 215 Threads: 0
Reputation:
2
Location: Norfolk
Car type: 1934 RP Saloon
We run an Ecoair desiccant dehumidifier 24/7 in our home, a 60 ton oak on oak Danish fishing boat. This uses approx 350 watts and has the advantage of no compressor or refrigerant. It gives out slightly warm dry air and has completely cured our condensation, clothes going mouldy in drawers etc and removes a couple of gallons of water a day.
Our Austin been kept in dehumidified storage for the last 10 years and comes out for it's infrequent trips in perfect condition.
I would recon any dehumidifier is better than none.
Joined: Aug 2017 Posts: 923 Threads: 52
Reputation:
5
Location: The delightful town of Knaresborough, North Yorkshire
My unbranded dehumidifier cuts in and out with it's humidistat and has been working for over 35 years now. It used to fill it's bucket in a few days but is now plumbed to outside and drips away. Without the dehumidifier it used to 'rain' inside the garage caused by condensation on the one clear panel in the roof.
Joined: Aug 2017 Posts: 124 Threads: 15
Reputation:
0
Location: Southern Cotswolds
Car type: '33 RP, '36 RTC Special, '39 Cambridge Special, '34 Wolseley Hornet Special, '50 Citroen Traction Avant
11-12-2018, 10:59 AM
(This post was last modified: 11-12-2018, 11:03 AM by Oxford Jack.)
Peter,
Twenty plus years ago I sold, amongst other things, dehums for a living. The company I worked for sold mostly refrigerant based dehums, but from time to time an application for desiccant units would arise. We sold to domestic, industrial and process applications and had a very good hire trade to the construction industry and flood restoration applications. A study and trial we carried out at the Rover factory in Oxford, was to prevent raw steel stock rusting in the former KD warehouse, it was a success but the big saving was in turning the heating off (which was unacceptable to the warehouse staff). This can be achieved if the humidity is kept below 45%. In cold conditions the amount of water vapour in the atmosphere at a given humidity is less than at the same humidity % when warm. The result is that a dehum will produce much less water at lower temperatures, which can result in queries about whether the unit is actually working.
It was a given at the the time that desiccant dehums worked better at lower temperatures than refrigerant units. I suggest that either your unit is working, but not producing much water or it is not and needs attention. To read the humidity accurately a hygrometer is required, we used a paper drum type to keep a weekly reading, but I suspect today a digital version will be available and probably cheaper.
The neat thing about dehums is that they produce more energy in heat than they use in driving the device, a net gain, so in a cold garage they are a very useful tool, but you do need a pretty air tight building to take full advantage of the effect.
You probably knew all this anyway, but I thought it might help. It reminded me of an occasion when in a new office building, the contractor requested hire dehums so that the building could be dried rapidly to meet the contract completion date. After two weeks despite an overkill of machines, the humidity level in the building had not reduced. I toured the building with the contract manager, who had pulled out all the workers until he could get in to do the final fit. I asked how the 25 litre catch tanks were maintained, he said they had a labourer on site ensuring the security lights stayed on and the machines were emptied. We found him and asked how often he dealt with the tanks, "Oh well sir, every evening they are full so I go round and empty them", "Where do you put the water?" "I just chuck it on the floor, its soon gone"?☘ ??
